Challenge Response: God Wrongly Punished Adam & Eve

Posted: June 14, 2012 by Brett Kunkle in Weekly Challenge

Here’s my response to this week’s challenge:

  1. DoubtingEric says:

    I have to imagine this is not a new challenge for christianity and judiasm’s account of the origin of sin. I would also have to imagine that apologists have been thinking about this for thousands of years. Is this the distillation of all of that thought? If so, it seems pretty unrefined and unconvincing to a skeptic such as myself. Of course, I could be wrong – perhaps this is a relatively new objection and no one has a good answer yet.